She's Miss, List, and Systi (Indong FN): Operating Profit Drops 20%, Yet Plundering 14 Billion Won in Dividends… Retreating Profitability, 87.3 Billion Won in Inventory, and a 69% Dividend Payout Ratio: 'Three Major Warning Lights'

  • 등록 2026.09.18 22:37:34
크게보기

 

[News Space=Reporter seungwon lee] Indong FN (CEO Jang Ki-kwon), a domestic mid-sized women's clothing company that operates the women's contemporary fashion brands SHESMISS, LIST, and SISTINA, saw a slight increase in sales in 2025, but its operating profit and net profit decreased by double digits.

 

In particular, while the operating profit margin retreated from 11.9% to 9.4%, the company's interim and final dividends totaled 14 billion won, amounting to 68.6% of net profit. Selling and administrative expenses increased, the gross profit margin decreased, and the growth rate of the cost of goods sold exceeded the growth rate of sales. The most uncomfortable aspect of this company's finances is that high dividends are the first thing to notice at a time when the quality of earnings and future investment capacity need to be assessed.

 

Indong FN has a structure in which Chairman Jang Gi-gwon firmly exercises management control as the largest shareholder, holding 104,000 shares (80.0%) based on 130,000 issued shares and a capital of 1.3 billion won. Lee Hyang-ro holds 13,000 shares (10.0%), and Jang Won-jun and Jang Ho-jun each hold 6,500 shares (5.0%), forming a closed ownership structure in which the combined stake of the four individuals, including the largest shareholder, reaches 100%.

 

Sales of 304.1 billion won, operating profit of 28.7 billion won… Revenue growth and profitability diverge

 

According to Indong FN's consolidated audit report registered on the Financial Supervisory Service's electronic disclosure system, sales in 2025 amounted to 304,050,320,000 won, an increase of 0.8% from 301,497,120,000 won in the previous year. While product sales increased by 3.4% to 221,378,150,000 won, merchandise sales decreased by 5.1% to 82,238,050,000 won, and other sales also fell by 44.3% to 434,120,000 won.

 

Gross profit was 184.61467 billion won, a 1.3% decrease from 187.06164 billion won in the previous year. The gross profit margin was 60.7%, down 1.3 percentage points from 62.0% in the previous year. This means that the amount remaining after deducting the cost of goods sold from 100 won in sales decreased compared to the previous year, which can be interpreted as cost burdens growing faster than revenue growth. Operating profit was 28.72679 billion won, a 19.8% decrease from 35.82312 billion won in the previous year, and the operating profit margin also fell to 9.4%, down 2.4 percentage points from 11.9% in the previous year. Net profit also decreased by 13.29% to 20.42237 billion won from 23.55494 billion won in the previous year.

 

Selling and administrative expenses increased by 3.1% to 155,887,870,000 won. Specifically, sales commissions amounted to 101,090,430,000 won, accounting for approximately 64.9% of total selling and administrative expenses, while salaries increased by 12.1% to 19,883,760,000 won. Advertising and promotional expenses rose by 4.3% to 4,010,520,000 won, while commission payments decreased by 8.6% to 3,394,950,000 won. The key point to examine is whether the burden of fixed and semi-fixed costs, such as salaries and sales commissions, pressured profitability downward in a situation where gross profit is shrinking, rather than the increase in selling and administrative expenses itself.

 

Net profit of 20.4 billion won and dividends of 14 billion won… Cash flow supported, but controversy over reinvestment capacity arises

 

According to the statement of appropriation of retained earnings, the company distributed a total of 14 billion won in dividends for 2025, including an interim dividend of 2 billion won and a final dividend of 12 billion won. The dividend per share was calculated at 107,693 won, combining the interim dividend of 15,385 won and the final dividend of 92,308 won, with the par value dividend rate for the final dividend alone being 923.08%. The company disclosed a dividend payout ratio of 68.55% for the current period, which is lower than the 76.42% of the previous year; however, considering the extent of the decline in net profit, this still represents a level where a significant portion of net profit has been transferred to shareholders.

 

Cash flow from operating activities amounted to 39.34838 billion won, approximately 1.93 times the net profit of 20.42237 billion won. This operating cash flow was supported by a decrease in inventory of 4.47488 billion won and a decrease in accounts receivable of 5.38773 billion won. However, in financing activities, a total outflow of 35.72288 billion won occurred as 15.72288 billion won in short-term borrowings was repaid and 20 billion won in dividends were paid. In other words, the dividend payout for 2025 was not only 68.6% of the net profit but also amounted to 20 billion won based on the actual dividend payments in the cash flow statement, indicating that the dividend policy played a significant role in cash management and financial decision-making.

 

The debt-to-equity ratio improved to 27.9%, but 64.1% of current assets are inventory

 

At the end of 2025, total liabilities amounted to 39.52834 billion won, a 26.0% decrease from 53.39455 billion won in the previous year. Total equity stood at 141.68 billion won, remaining virtually unchanged from the previous year, and the debt-to-equity ratio improved to 27.9% from 37.7% in the previous year. Current liabilities decreased by 26.3% to 38.49905 billion won from 52.24722 billion won in the previous year, while short-term borrowings plummeted from 16.04279 billion won to 297.14 million won.

 

Looking solely at liquidity indicators, current assets amount to 136.199 billion won and current liabilities to 38.499 billion won, resulting in a current ratio of 353.8%. Cash and cash equivalents stood at 12.067 billion won, a 37.4% increase from 8.785 billion won in the previous year. However, inventory accounts for approximately 64.1% of current assets, amounting to 87.300 billion won. The allowance for inventory valuation totals 7.360 billion won, comprising 5.549 billion won in finished goods, 1.223 billion won in merchandise, and 533.92 million won in raw materials. This is why it is difficult to conclude that the potential for converting assets into cash is sufficient based solely on the fact that the current ratio is high.

 

10 Billion Won Investment in Vietnam Subsidiary Disappears from Books… Significance of Changes in Consolidation Scope

 

Disclosures regarding related parties and overseas business highlight the investment risks associated with Indong FN. In the previous period, the company invested 6,044,410,000 KRW in cash and lent 2,185,460,000 KRW to INDONG FN VINA CO.,LTD, in which it held a 100% stake as of the end of the previous year. As of the end of the previous period, the entity's total assets were 12,925,020,000 KRW, total liabilities were 2,927,430,000 KRW, revenue was 225,540,000 KRW, and net loss was 2,992,390,000 KRW.

 

In 2025, the book value of this company's equity method investment of 9,997,140,000 won decreased due to a change in the scope of consolidation, resulting in an ending book value of 0 won. While this appears in the report as a result of its inclusion as a subsidiary in the 2025 consolidated financial statements, it is necessary to separately verify the circumstances under which the overseas entity, which had a book value of approximately 10 billion won in the previous year, underwent a change in the scope of consolidation and whether its business has been normalized.

 

Allegations regarding royalties, owner compensation, lawsuits, and abuse of power were not confirmed in the audit report

 

Specific disclosures supporting the payment of royalties to the headquarters, salaries and retirement benefits for key executives, and the owner's abuse of power, corruption, or moral hazard cannot be found in the attached audit report. The report lists the book value of trademarks as 1,194,870,000 won, the acquisition cost for the current period as 1,146,000 won, and amortization expenses for intangible assets as 170,380,000 won.

 

A corporate financial analysis expert pointed out, “While sales remained virtually stagnant, operating profit fell by 19.8% as the cost of goods sold and selling and administrative expenses increased faster than sales. Although the reduction of debt and securing operating cash flow are positive aspects, the decision to distribute 68.6% of net profit as dividends raises questions regarding reinvestment capacity and long-term growth strategies at a time when profitability is slowing.” The expert added, “In particular, the circumstances surrounding last year’s investments in overseas subsidiaries and changes in the scope of consolidation, the potential for converting inventory into cash, and the sales commission structure are key pain points that shareholders and creditors must verify.”

 

Meanwhile, Indong FN did not provide any response to News Space's requests for coverage and inquiries. 

 

◆ Below is the full text of the questionnaire sent by News Space to Indong FN

 

Question 1. Causes of sales stagnation and sharp decline in operating profit, and liability

In 2025, sales reached 304,050,320,000 KRW, a mere 0.8% increase from the previous year's 301,497,120,000 KRW; meanwhile, operating profit fell by 19.8% to 28,726,790,000 KRW from the previous year's 35,823,120,000 KRW. During the same period, the operating profit margin also dropped by 2.4 percentage points, from 11.9% to 9.4%. Which factor—such as rising costs, sales commissions, changes in product mix, discounts and inventory depletion, or exchange rates—does the company attribute the primary cause of this deterioration in profitability? Furthermore, please explain who the decision-making body was that ultimately approved and took responsibility for this analysis of causes and the improvement measures.

 

Question 2. Background of the Cost of Goods Sold Growth Rate Exceeding the Sales Growth Rate

Cost of sales was 119,435,660,000 KRW, a 4.4% increase from 114,435,480,000 KRW in the previous year, while sales growth was limited to 0.8%. Consequently, gross profit decreased by 1.3% to 184,614,670,000 KRW, and the gross profit margin also fell from 62.0% to 60.7%. Does the company view the rise in cost ratios as a temporary factor, or as a result of structural changes in the product portfolio and pricing policy? If there are specific management targets confirmed by the Board of Directors or management to improve cost ratios and gross profit margins by 2026, please present them within the scope of what can be disclosed.

 

Question 3. Structure of the 101 billion won sales commission and conflict of interest management

Selling and administrative expenses amounted to 155,887,870,000 KRW, a 3.1% increase from the previous year; of this, sales commissions accounted for 101,090,430,000 KRW, or approximately 64.9%. Please explain the sales channels, transaction structures, and contract types from which these sales commissions are generated, as well as the reasons for the year-on-year fluctuations. Additionally, please confirm whether the recipients of these sales commissions include corporations or related companies in which related parties or the owner's family hold direct or indirect equity. If so, please verify whether transaction approval procedures and reviews of external comparable prices or arm's length prices were conducted.

 

Question 4. Linkage between increases in salaries and advertising expenses and business performance

Among selling, general, and administrative expenses, salaries amounted to 19,883,760,000 KRW, a 12.1% increase from the previous year, and advertising and promotional expenses also rose by 4.3% to 4,010,520,000 KRW. Conversely, operating profit decreased by 19.8%. Please explain by distinguishing which factors contributed to the increase in salaries: personnel expansion, wage hikes, performance bonuses, executive compensation, or organizational restructuring. Please also answer whether you operate a system for retrospective evaluation of sales, margins, and brand performance regarding the execution of advertising and promotional expenses and personnel costs, and whether there are procedures in place to hold individuals accountable or adjust the budget if performance is unsatisfactory.

 

Question 5. Criteria for determining a dividend payout ratio of 68.55% during a phase of declining net profit

Although the net profit for 2025 was 20,422,370,000 KRW, a 13.3% decrease from the previous year, the company distributed a total of 14 billion KRW in dividends, including an interim dividend of 2 billion KRW and a final dividend of 12 billion KRW, recording a dividend payout ratio of 68.55%. What criteria did the company apply when determining the size of these dividends, and was the dividendable amount determined after calculating the funds required for future investment, employment, working capital, and financial stability? Please explain, to the extent possible for public disclosure, the cash flow forecasts and investment plans reviewed by the Board of Directors or the General Meeting of Shareholders during the dividend decision process.

 

Question 6. Priority of dividends and debt repayment and equity among shareholders

According to the 2025 Cash Flow Statement, the company paid out 20 billion won in dividends and repaid 15.72 billion won in short-term borrowings, resulting in a net outflow of 35.72 billion won in cash flow from financing activities. Since the dividend amount listed in the Statement of Appropriation of Retained Earnings in the audit report is 14 billion won, we would like to verify the reason for the discrepancy between the resolved dividend amount in accounting and the actual payment of 20 billion won in the Cash Flow Statement. Please provide a specific explanation as to whether this difference is due to dividend payments from the previous year, differences in the timing of interim and final dividend payments, or other reasons. Furthermore, please state which criterion—borrowing repayment or dividends—was prioritized, and whether the company plans to maintain the same dividend policy in the future.

 

Question 7. Cashability of 87.3 Billion Won in Inventory Assets and Inventory Risk

As of the end of 2025, current assets amounted to 136,199,050,000 KRW, of which inventory assets accounted for 87,300,520,000 KRW, or approximately 64.1%. The allowance for inventory valuation also totaled approximately 7,360,890,000 KRW, comprising 5,549,040,000 KRW in finished goods, 1,223,130,000 KRW in merchandise, and 533,920,000 KRW in raw materials. How does the company manage the age composition of inventory and the proportion of inventory available for sale versus low-turnover and obsolete inventory? Please explain how you assess the possibility of additional losses arising from discount sales, disposal, or returns, and the basis for your assessment that the current allowance for valuation is sufficient.

 

Question 8. Actual liquidity of a current ratio of 353.8% and cash management

The current ratio is high at 353.8%, and cash and cash equivalents amounted to 12.0672 billion won, a 37.4% increase from the previous year. However, as a significant portion of current assets consists of inventory, there may be a discrepancy between accounting liquidity and actual cashability. Does the company separately manage indicators of pure cash liquidity excluding inventory? Additionally, please provide details on how much of the cash equivalents were planned to be allocated to dividends, new investments, operating funds, and borrowing repayments by the end of 2025, and whether the current level of cash holdings meets the minimum operating fund requirements.

 

Question 9. Investment Feasibility for the Vietnam Subsidiary and Changes in Consolidation Scope

In the previous period, the Company invested 6,044,410,000 KRW in cash and lent 2,185,460,000 KRW to INDONG FN VINA CO.,LTD, in which it holds a 100% stake. However, at the end of the previous period, the said entity recorded sales of 225,540,000 KRW and a net loss of 2,992,390,000 KRW. Furthermore, in 2025, the book value of the equity method investment, approximately 9,997,140,000 KRW, decreased due to a change in the scope of consolidation, resulting in a year-end book value of 0 KRW. Please explain what business viability, recoverability, and profit/loss outlook the Company reviewed at the time of deciding on the investment and loan, and identify which organization or board of directors was responsible for and approved the investment feasibility review and subsequent performance evaluation at that time. Additionally, please disclose the specific reasons for the change in the scope of consolidation, the current sales, profit/loss, and capital impairment status of the Vietnamese entity, and if there are any plans for additional financial support, to the extent possible for public disclosure.

 

Question 10. Verification of Independence and Arm's Length Price of Related Party Transactions and Fund Transactions

The audit report lists transactions with INDONG FN VINA CO., LTD, a related party based on the previous period, including purchases of 116.19 million won and receivables of 28.94 million won. Additionally, financial transactions include a cash contribution of 6.04441 billion won and loans of 2.18546 billion won. Please provide an answer as to whether these transactions were conducted under the same conditions as those with general business partners, and what the interest rate, maturity, collateral, and repayment terms were for the loans. Please also verify whether the counterparty's equity, executives, or effective control are connected to the owner or the CEO, and whether conflict of interest control procedures, such as prior approval, subsequent review, and reporting to an external auditor, were followed for these related-party transactions.

 

Question 11. Transparency of governance and decision-making accountability

The 2025 audit report specifies that the 2024 comparative financial statements were not audited, and the audit opinion for 2025 is presented as unqualified. How does the Company explain that the audit opinion signifies that the financial statements are fairly presented in all material terms, but it does not constitute a guarantee of the validity of all management decisions or the effectiveness of internal controls? In particular, regarding the decline in operating profit margin, high dividends, concentration of inventory assets, investments in overseas subsidiaries, and related-party transactions, please provide an answer as to what data the Board of Directors reviewed and on what criteria it approved these matters, and whether there were any external or independent review mechanisms in place. Furthermore, please clarify whether there are plans to revise the review procedures for dividends, related-party transactions, and overseas investments in 2026 to enhance the accountability and transparency of such decision-making.

 

이승원 기자 alexblack7@naver.com
저작권자 © 뉴스스페이스(NewsSpace) 무단전재 및 재배포 금지
93건의 관련기사 더보기





서울시 서초구 사평대로 140 코웰빌딩 B1, 318호 | 대표전화 : 0505-546-0505 | 팩스 : 0505-548-0505 제호 : 뉴스스페이스(NewsSpace) | 등록번호 : 서울 아 54727 | 등록일 : 2023-03-07 | 발행일 : 2023-03-07 발행·편집인 : 이현주 | 청소년보호책임자 : 김정영 | 법률자문 : 이수동 변호사(법률사무소 이수) Copyright © 2024 뉴스스페이스(NewsSpace). All rights reserved.